These teams were selected by coaches of the member MIAA schools.

Football
- B.J. Watson
- Morgan Scroggins
- Tyshon Fogg

Soccer
- Sam Loeffler
- Jeff Schaefer
- Camilo Sanchez
- Dom Fullano

Volleyball
- Nate Bosse
- Nate Reynolds

Water Polo
- Brenden White
- Jeff Brady
- Alex Cappuccio
- Cullen Seipp